Movie Notes: Avatar
December 20th, 2009
![]()
= 5 stars
Starring Sam Worthington, Sigourney Weaver, Zoe Saldana
Directed by James Cameron
Synopsis
Future humans descend upon the planet Pandora to mine its resources, but native aliens called Na’vi are getting in the way. Marine Jake Sully (Sam Worthington) is mentally linked to a human-grown Na’vi clone called an “avatar” and sent to infiltrate the tribe, in hopes of negotiation.
The Good
- Amazing, completely immersive CGI. With the exception of the blue Navi (a mere inch away from crossing the uncanny valley) and the human actors, I couldn’t tell what was real vs. CGI. The jungle landscape is flawlessly detailed and mesmerizing. But the illusion is maintained in simpler ways: camera movements and cuts are reality based (shaky, human camera moves and zooms), the human scenes seem filmed in HD plus lighting that lends a near CGI look, and the plot rarely has the CGI Na’vi and actual humans interacting with one another.
- Satisfyingly primal plot of good vs. evil: think Star Wars but humans as the Empire, more specifically, the military working in cahoots with a profit-first corporation, and the cutesy innocent indigenous aliens along with the wussy scientists as the rebels. Then sprinkle Dances With Wolves, Little Big Man, Lord of the Rings, Princess Mononoke, and Braveheart. There’s even a requisite, cartoony, over-the-top villain in the form of Colonel Quaritch (Steven Lang). The human military vehicles, all steel, metal and fire commanded by translucent touch monitors, are a great contrast to the green, bioluminescent, vegitative natural environment.
- Eventually became caught up in the Na’vi’s fate, specifically through a few emotionally effective scenes where Na’vi Neytiri (Zoe Saldana) reacts to the hellish destruction of their world. I’m also very glad Cameron included one moment where Neytiri meets Jake himself, instead of only interacting with his avatar.
- Nearly three hours long, and I barely noticed.
- Much to my surprise, the spouse liked it – responded to the environmental message.
The Bad
- I found the “avatar” concept hard to swallow, and it ultimately seemed a contrivance to provide an “entry point” into a new, foreign culture – basically believing an audience can’t relate unless there’s some (human) character like them to personally identify with.
- A few unintentionally funny moments: The Na’vi make the cliched, head-slapping mistake to welcome Jake into their culture. One wonders what happens to Jake’s avatar body while he’s awake – it seems it’s just left lying about until his return. There’s a group-hug thing at a sea-anemone tree that took me out of the moment, and an alien sex scene (thankfully, no bizarre blue genitalia) between Jake and the Na’vi chick you just know he’ll fall for. I was occasionally reminded of A Bugs Life (save our home) or even the Smurfs (the tribe doesn’t have much individuality or dissent). Lastly, there are stock action movie cliches – the good guys of course escape from jail, and the bad guy must survive a plane crash. Taking a step back, the weak plot takes this odd movie dangerously close to ridiculousness.
Conclusion
Despite plot quibbles, and waffling between 4 and 5 stars, the overwhelming CGI won over even this CGI-o-phobe to squeak into a low 5 stars. Ultimately, Avatar is an epic, barn burner movie that begs to be seen on the big screen – an increasing rarity. Its marriage of CGI and a cartoony, good verses evil on an alien world results in a movie George Lucas surely wishes he had made. He’s probably green – or Avatar blue – with envy right now.
IMDB: Avatar
Wikipedia: Avatar
Rotten Tomatoes: Avatar 83%
I agree, the story is kind of weak. Preachy and predictable, but the innovation is pretty amazing and you get your money's worth in the detail they put into Pandora. I was actually sad to leave it when the movie was over. What did you think of the 3D? I found it distracting — called attention to itself. I'm actually going to see it again in 2D.
Saw it in 2D. Doubt I'll see it in 3D or IMAX, but this would be one to
check out in HD eventually.
very very very very very good….
Very nice movie! Although I'm curious if the colors would be a lot more vivid without the tint of the 3D glasses.
[...] usually during that dangerous area where human actors interact with computer-generated ones. Unlike Avatar, the visuals aren’t amazing enough to make up for the mediocre [...]