Webomatica

 

Too Anti-Social For Social Media

June 28th, 2009

It’s been a nice weekend enjoying the sunny weather – but I’ve had a bit more time to consider the implications of taking a break from FriendFeed, what it says about myself, and social media in general.

I’ve basically decided my involvement in social media over the past few years has been a very mixed bag, and on a deeper level – somewhat of a farce.

In the offline world, away from the Internet, I am a loner; an introvert. I have no qualms using the negative descriptor “anti-social.” While I have a core group of friends, co-workers, family, and a loving wife and two cats – I don’t travel much beyond a sphere of a handful of people – I like a small circle. I get stressed out when in large groups, and socializing tends to be a distraction from a long list of productive things I could be doing alone. I’m at my best “one on one,” dislike having more than one or two scheduled “social events” in a week, and literally need alone time to “re-charge” by myself.

Fellow introverts should be nodding their heads in familiar agreement.

Blog?

But wait, you write this blog. Isn’t that the definition of egotism and extroversion? Well, not in my case. My posts have always been opining on movies and technology and Apple stuff. What I don’t blog about should be revealing: I don’t write about my day job, family, or personal life – basically the vast majority of my life. The above paragraphs are the most personal ones I’ve written in the past year. Privacy is constantly on my mind and the blog displays only one small slice of my personality, and not often mentioned in my daily, offline life. I keep a pretty tight wall between online and offline.

So why blog? Truth be told, it’s more to keep track of my own thoughts in database form. So I can look back on all the movies I’ve seen and figure out which are the best. I’d continue this way for years – with the comments shut off – and be pretty well satisfied.

Pretending To Be Something I’m Not

With all that as a preface – my involvement in social media began as a means to introduce the Internet at large to some solitary obsessions. But in the process of promoting the blog, has turned in a rather disingenuous game, where I pretend to be “social”: interested, open, welcoming thousands of followers, mesmerized by sparkling conversation – when I deep down, I could care less. I also admit to feeling that by being social online, it might get me to come out of my shell and become more social in real life.

Well, that never happened. Actually, it’s probably made things worse as far as the offline world is concerned.

I’m at the point where there’s no point in trying to turn an orange into an apple. This is some testament to how “social” the online world has become – it mimics real life so well that I find myself getting uncomfortable and annoyed in the same manner during a social event in the “real world.” FriendFeed is literally, often like a cocktail party, with tons of people chatting and tossing opinions about – I don’t feel comfortable at parties.

(Looking back with some navel-gazing, this explains my history of “quitting” services. I quit Twitter, quit Facebook, and quit Google Reader – all social, popularity tracking stuff. Meanwhile, I’ve stuck with movies, television, and iPhone apps – largely solitary activities.)

The Cat Nerd At The UNIX Workstation

Lastly: I first got into computers back in the eighties as a teenager, partly because that’s what introverted kids, who weren’t interested in popularity contests (sports) did. Very pleasing was operating in an electronic world that one could control alone. When you get into creation (music, art, programming), you are the master of your own domain, the creator of your own cosmos.

Things were just peachy for years, until the Internet started taking over. For a while, it was all manageable through email and a browser, but then a few years ago, all this social stuff started piling on. This whole deal with “followers” is a simulation of the very popularity contests (sports) I avoid.

Looking back, I got into computers to get away from people. Now “everyone else” has showed up and thinks computers are communication tools; a socializing wonderland.

The computer lab has been invaded by jocks and cheerleaders, throwing a party, maybe having loud sex on a workstation or something. Meanwhile, one nerd in the corner (who loves cats – doesn’t that say it all?) just wants to get some coding done, and wonders what the heck happened to the peace and quiet.

RSS Feed Please subscribe to the Webomatica RSS Feed!

  • It's one of the reasons I stopped updating my blog last year... the pressure (responsibility) to stay engaged with my audience, especially as traffic grew. I'm a loner who works in a highly social industry (theatre) and at the end of a long day of being social at work, I just don't have the energy to socialize online (though I've been dipping my toe back into blogging). I still enjoy Twitter and Facebook, but more as a reader than as a contributor.

    Just last night I posted this on Facebook: "Catching up with a week's worth of status updates. I think I'm better suited to anti-social networking."

    Glad I'm not the only one.

    -Daniel
  • Yeah, I've also been retreating back to the core of Facebook and Twitter -
    not currently on Facebook, but getting very close to activating my account
    again and setting everything to private save a handful of real world folks.
    Then Twitter takes care of everything else.
    Please, nobody set up an antisocial network. It'd be really hard to gain
    members.
  • <nods head>
    I keep trying to make a go of social networks, but I agree that it's usually too much like trying to start a conversation at a party where everyone else knows each other and is talking about something else.
    Still, I'm sticking with it for now. If it continues to be an unprofitable and unpleasant experience I may find myself slowly withdrawing over time. Unfortunately I doubt many will notice or care. I suppose that's OK, though.
  • Definitely give it a good shot. There have been some benefits - a few folks
    I know only online that I fully intend to keep in touch with, and has led to
    some fun opportunities I wouldn't have had otherwise.
    But at the end of this experiment I feel pretty confident in saying the old
    adage "it's not for me." And I've found it a pretty large distraction from
    other things I really should be spending more time on - stuff that I'm
    pretty confident will make me happier in the long run.
  • Interesting new media, but they consume a lot of time.
  • I think this is an excellent blog post -- exactly what I look for in personal writing: honest and very insightful. It's a very rich irony, isn't it, that social media networks are invented by exactly the kind of people who are least likely to crave great amounts of social interaction? Maybe that's why they don't really *work* very well...

    Someday some big brain at Stanford will tell us what we were really engaging in all this time.
  • I guess no social network has discovered some magical "social media" formula
    similar to Google's PageRank alogrithm...
blog comments powered by Disqus