Cautionary Blog Advertising Tales
Here are two posts regarding the subject of blog advertising that I found interesting:
- David Airey who believes his blog is being penalized by Google in their search results as the result of a few paid links. The item of contention seems to be the lack of “nofollow” on said paid links, implying that his site was giving an SEO benefit to them for cash. This is a no-no as far as Google is concerned. His site may have been reported to Google after he posted about buying and selling links in a forum. Whether or not you agree with Google’s policy, it is interesting to see how quickly this Google penalty was enacted, the effect on his listing in Google search results, and the resulting negative effect on traffic.
- Mr. Simplehelp posts about his recent experience turning down someone who offered him $550 for a “lifetime” contract link. He asked a few other bloggers what they would do in this situation and the general consensus was the “lifetime” part was not to Simplehelp’s benefit, and the effect on SEO - especially the potential links to “spammy sites” was not worth the $550.
Both these points demonstrate the caution I believe bloggers should have when it comes to monetization and ads. There may be an initial impulse to go crazy with monetization and take whatever comes your way. But I think it’s good to balance the SEO implications of any ads you run, and even the effect on your readers. You may line your pockets but is it worth it if your position in Google lowers or if readers run away because you have turned your site into a billboard?
On Webomatica I’ve had occasional offers to buy links but I still persist with my policy of no paid links. So far, I only have Google AdSense, Amazon, and iTunes affiliates. I may set up a system for advertising in the future but it will be on my terms and rotate monthly. I have considered TextLink Ads but due to my general trend of procrastination I haven’t gotten around to it.
At the end of the day, no legitimate site needs to pay me for a link from this blog. All you have to do is comment, and get by my increasingly draconian blog spam filters. I also check out every site to see if the content is something I could stand linking to. But if you get by that, and have something constructive to say about what I’ve written, you’re golden.
That might be a fair amount of work but the link won’t cost you a dime.
Front Page
Jason,
I have had Text-Link-Ads since pretty wel when they first came out - or at least on and off in 2 to 3 month periods. How much have I made from them … $0.00
I believe that for smaller blogs - growing or not - Text-Link-Ads are generally a waste of time with the only one’s benefiting from them is Text-Link-Ads.
Heh - oh yeah. I like to know the reality of the experience for others. I guess that’s more fuel for my procrastination.
Thanks for the mention. It’s odd how I’ve been penalised, without knowing exactly what the reason is. Sure, I have a fair idea, but it could be one of two things - either the paid links using ‘dofollow’ or the prize giveaway I’m running that’s attracted a couple of hundred backlinks over a three week period.
I’d love to know which, and of course how long I’m penalised for.
David - I’d have to guess the paid links thing. Lots of backlinks I can’t really see Google penalizing anyone for. I’ve gone through odd spikes in traffic, mostly caused by being on social news sites, that caused a lot of backlinks over a short period of time, and all it did was increase my rank in the search results for those particular posts…