Zune Wireless: Not So Great

October 3rd, 2006

TechnologyWell, the more I learn about the Zune I’m thinking Microsoft may be making some serious mistakes. Engadget has a pretty blunt article about how the Zune’s wireless isn’t as functional as it should be.

This is unfortunate, because it’s already well established what WiFi does in the minds of most consumers. It’s the technology that allows hardware wireless access to the internet or a local network. So whenever a device is said to support it, it’s assumed you can use it for copying files from a computer to said device or ideally, or use it to browse the web.

So it’s disappointing to learn that supposedly, the Zune WiFi will allow you transfer songs (and photos) from one Zune to another, albiet with some DRM restrictions. Second, you won’t be able to use the Zune to connect to the web, or sync to your computer.

This last item is worth emphasizing because it seems like the biggest no-brainer of all. Syncing to a home computer via WiFI to transfer files would have been the biggest use of the Zune WiFi for most people (since there aren’t likely to be tons of other Zunes out there for people to share music with, right off the bat).

I’m certain if/when Apple comes out with a WiFi iPod, they won’t limit the functionality of WiFi in this manner, and the Zune’s will be seen as a huge missed opportunity by Microsoft.

I’m hoping an Apple WiFi iPod will allow networked music sharing, exactly how music libraries are treated in iTunes: you can listen to music other people’s iPods with sharing on, but not copy the files over. That alone would be an awesome, killer functionality for the iPod while simultaneously addressing piracy fears. Second, copying files from a computer to the iPod is an obvious, needed feature.

Disclosure: I own a tiny amount of Apple stock.

4 comments!

  1. comment Gravatar Zune - October 4th, 2006

    The second or third generation of the Zune should be the right one. The fisrt generation is always for early adopters.

  2. comment Gravatar webomatica - October 4th, 2006

    I’m pretty sure that by the time the second or third generation Zune comes out, apple will have moved ahead also.

    We’ll see. I’m holding out final judgement until I see a Zune in the flesh, in a store where I can play with it. But so far I’m not seeing anything killer that makes me want to trade in my iPod Video.

  3. comment Gravatar Harold - November 26th, 2006

    Can’t wait for that new Iphone to come out.

    By the time Zune have figured out how to make a real mp3, apple will have every technology in the ipod, maybe even cameras next.

  4. comment Gravatar webomatica - November 26th, 2006

    Yeah Harold, you are right about that. I’m hoping an iPod phone shows up sometime in early 2007. If Steve Jobs announces one at MacWorld, I’ll be jumping up and down!

Please comment!